Why the dinosaurs’ extinction is an ongoing puzzle
Dinosaurs ruled the world for roughly 140 million years—until they suddenly disappeared. While decades of research point to an asteroid impact at Chicxulub crater as the end of the dinosaurs' reign 66 million years ago, scientists weren't always so sure what happened to these mesmerizing creatures. Theories varied wildly throughout the twentieth century as the field of paleontology grew, but it wasn't until the 1980s that one theory emerged as a major breakthrough in the extinction mystery. Today's scientists continue to piece together the puzzle with discoveries that give us a clearer picture of what happened to the dinosaurs.
Transcript
This happened about 66 million years ago.
The impact was as powerful as 10 billion atomic bombs, and the catastrophic global effects on the environment were even deadlier.
75% of all life on earth went extinct including a dominant group of animals that has come to mesmerize our attention.
The diversity that we see in dinosaurs is really a reflection of how successful they were.
Meet Nat Geo Explorer Diego Pol, one of the paleontologists who discovered the largest dinosaur ever.
Dinosaurs were predominant in our world for over 140 million years. Humans have been on this planet for 200,000 years.
And there's not many cases in the history of our planet that one group is so predominant and so successful for such a long time.
Humans and dinosaurs didn’t overlap, not even close, and as we’ve seen in Hollywood we can be thankful for that.
But dinosaur fossils left humans wondering, where’d they go?
Dinosaur extinction has been a fascinating topic for a long, long time. We see their presence up to 66 million years old, and then after that there's nothing. They’re gone.
Throughout the twentieth century, there were a lot of arguments. Theories varied dramatically, from the somewhat plausible to the downright bizarre. Some pointed to out-of-control hormones or cataracts. Others blamed a world taken over by hungry caterpillars.
The answers eluded experts until 1980 when two scientists working here discovered a clue.
The link to it being an asteroid impact started almost by accident. Walter Alvarez, and his father, Luis Alvarez, were actually very interested in a place called Gubbio, Italy. There were limestones that were Cretaceous and then there were limestones that were after the Cretaceous, what we call the Paleogene. And the extinction event was right at that boundary.”
Instead of finding anything background and normal, they actually found a spike in something called iridium. Iridium is a surprise because we have very little iridium present on the surface of the earth versus what the asteroids are made of.
Walter and Luis Alvarez co-authored a groundbreaking paper, hypothesizing that an asteroid was responsible for the mass extinction. But that in itself, raised another question. Where’s the crater?
Scientists dug further into the layer of iridium for answers.
The real key clue was while it's only a centimeter-thick layer in most of the world, as you approach the Gulf of Mexico, that layer becomes much, much thicker. We start seeing layers that are a meter thick, or even hundreds of meters thick in places, as you get closer and closer to the place where the impact happened.
By the early 90s the science was becoming more convincing. More than a mile below the surface of the Yucatan Peninsula laid a saucer shaped structure different from volcanic terrain. This was the Chicxulub Crater.
So to answer the fundamental questions about how this particular impact caused a mass extinction event, we needed to drill into it.
Where it actually hit was limestones, so calcium carbonate, which makes a lot of CO2 when you vaporize it. But even more important perhaps were evaporates. These are rocks that are high in sulfur. And so when those get vaporized, they actually put native sulfur into the atmosphere, which when combined with water becomes sulfate aerosols, which is a pollutant, that actually succeeds in cooling the planet off.
If it had happened a little bit earlier, or a little bit later, in terms of rotation of the earth. It could have easily hit the Atlantic Ocean or the Pacific Ocean and entirely missed this shelf environment with all these sediments beneath it. And if it had done that, most the material that would have been ejected would have been the vaporized asteroid and just water.
Where it hit and with the energy it hit seemed to have had the right recipe to create a global catastrophe.
Dinosaurs were living in a vulnerable time leading up to the asteroid. But perhaps more surprising is the realization that not all dinosaurs went extinct.
So most people think that dinosaurs are extinct, but this is completely false. Because if you look out your window, you're going to see a living dinosaur.
As a vertebrate paleontologist my specialty is understanding how birds evolved from dinosaurs, and then also how the earliest birds evolved into what we would consider a bird today. You have this huge diversity of dinosauria, and then you have one group that's called the theropoda. And everybody knows therapods it includes famous members like Velociraptor or T-Rex. But one group of theropods eventually gave way to birds.”
This resilient group of theropods is represented today by over 10,000 living species of birds.
Modern birds is the most diverse clade of vertebrates living on land on the planet today. So people are always saying that like, "This is the age of the mammals," and I always like to joke and be like, "It's still the age of the dinosaurs!"
While the dinosaur extinction mystery has come a long way since the early theories, discoveries today are still necessary pieces of the bigger picture.
You have to like puzzles. A discovery it's certainly important, but it will not answer all your questions. It will be a big and important piece in your puzzle.
Mass extinction events are incredibly powerful tools for us to understand the way life and ecosystems operate. And so the Chicxulub event, is the most recent of these mass extinction events on earth.
Science is never done, right? We just find more questions that need answering.